The ongoing contribution of Peter McCue started with his life in Illinois and then Texas. This time we will delve into his influence that moves from Texas to Oklahoma. We will start with one of his daughters. A mare associated with three names Carrie Nation, Oakford Belle and Belle Of Oakford.
CARRIE NATION
Carrie Nation has been reported through the history of South Texas Quarter Horse racing that she was a great race mare by Peter McCue. We will start her story with Peter McCue standing in Oakford, Illinois, with George Watkins. The information comes from the Bob Denhardt book The Quarter Running Horse. Denhardt writes “Carrie Nation was one of Peter McCue’s fastest fillies. According to William E. Boeker, she was raised by George Watkins and Ed King of Oakford, Illinois. King, who had a grocery business in Oakford, had a neat mare that pulled a delivery wagon. He bred her to Peter McCue, who was handled by George Watkins, a friend. When the mare foaled, they named the filly Carrie Nation. Her speed soon made her a marked horse, and Ed and George sold her. In Oakford every Saturday, according to old timers, was Carrie Nation day. She defeated all comers, including such well-known horses as Burnt Black, Coyote and Gatlin Gun. She was never defeated on the Oakford track. She never started in a walk up, or by a turn when facing away from the starting line, but from an open chute with her nose on the starting line. She would stand quietly in the chute to wait for the starting signal. She did not care how her opponents started as long as they were not past the starting line when the signal was given.”
He continued, “She drew crowds from as a far away as Springfield and Peoria. When Jim Thomas died in 1906, her new owners took her to Texas. She was one of the very best sprinters of her day.” So according to this story Carrie Nation was known by that name from the beginning. And at this point her dam has no known pedigree.
The pedigree of Carrie Nation is like many pedigrees we see in these times it has its own discrepancies. We don’t know the pedigree of the dam in the story above. When we look at a list of known offspring for Peter McCue, we come up with a mare Oakford Belle. She was foaled in 1904 and out of Little Easter by The Hero, and her dam was Trixey W by Fib. She was bred by John Watkins and later owned by John Braden of Lewiston, Illinois. Oakford Belle has been credited as the name they used to give Carrie Nation a Thoroughbred pedigree.
In a letter written by John Wilkens to Ott Adams dated December 17, 1919, he tells Adams that he bought Carrie Nation for $1,000. He says that “she was the fastest Quarter Horse” he ever saw. The mare was a well-known runner in South Texas. One of her races was with Little Joe, the famous stallion raced by George Clegg and later owned by Ott Adams. Gatlin Gun was virtually unbeatable except for one race. But he defeated Carrie Nation in their race.
Wilkens writes in the letter to Ott Adams that a mare named Belle Of Oakford was the Thoroughbred name for Carrie Nation. This mare was foaled in 1899. She was sired by Bowling Green, and her dam was Trixey W by Fib. Trixey W was the dam of Little Easter the dam of Oakford Belle. When we look at Thoroughbred Pedigree Query, we see that Belle Of Oakford was bred by Fred Atterbury and owned by John Wilkens.
The most famous foal of Carrie Nation was Billy Sunday, and he is listed as being bred by John Wilkens. He was sired by a Thoroughbred named Horace H and out of Carrie Nation, which was the Quarter Horse version of his pedigree. He was also registered as a Thoroughbred named Huyler, sired by Horace H and out of Belle Of Oakford. Victoria Short in her biography of Billy Sunday in her book Unregistered Sires Of The American Quarter Horse tells us that Helen Michaelis thought this was an error and she backed up that Oakford Belle was Carrie Nation. Short reported that Milo Burlingame, an owner of Peter McCue stated that Oakford Belle was Carrie Nation.
Belle Of Oakford produced five Thoroughbred foals that show up in Thoroughbred Pedigree Query records. They include a colt named Edgar Uhl, plus the fillies Lady Wilkens, Lilly White, and Marian Mueller, all by Horace H. Lilly White is the dam of Sissy C by Uncle Jimmie Gray. Sissy C was the dam of Just Sissy the dam of the AAA/ROM runner John Red by Red Man by Joe Hancock by John Wilkens by Peter McCue. John Red is the sire of Boyd Flick. Boyd Flick is the dam of Flick Bar AAAT, Leota Flick AAA, Leota Gal AAA and Mr Flick AAA.
La Cometa by Peter McCue was another…



